Western Autumn After “Arab Spring?”
Why did Britain burn from 6-10August 2011? What made rioters take innocent lives, loot shops, and set them on fire? How could Anders Behring Breivik murder 91 fellow Norwegians in cold blood on 22July? Why did Greeks go to the streets in May-June, protesting against $153 billion being offered to bail out their economy? At the start of this decade, who would have predicted that in less than two years: It may be too late to save the euro . . . the critical question is: Can America be saved from the evil that has gripped so much of its family, education, religion, economy, politics, law, media, and entertainment? Most importantly, what must India learn from the Western folly? We would all love to see the Arab world liberated and transformed, but I never expected the “Arab Spring” to bring forth the kind of blossoms that secular pundits expected from it. The secular intellectuals are clever. They have succeeded in turning Wall Street into a casino that makes many of them super-wealthy while bankrupting their nation. If individual wealth is the litmus test of success then Arab despots may have done better than Wall Street moguls. In fact, the secular worldview is simply too naïve to understand the West or teach the Arab world how to build a civilization that is free and just with equal opportunity for all. Sadly, secular intellectuals think that material factors and accidents of history such as “Guns, Germs, and Steel” (Jared Diamond) or Biology, Sociology, and Geography (Ian Morris) can account for freedom. They think that nation-building is about economic “killer apps” (Niall Ferguson) rather than ideas, morals, and culture. Rather than being helpful, such amoral economic experts, produced by Ivy League universities, are driving Western nations into bankruptcy. While I remain sceptical about the Arab Spring, I am more confident about the Western Autumn ushering in a terrible winter. My short-term pessimism is produced by the underlying causes of the two phenomena. The Arab Spring It was a terrible tragedy that triggered the protests that were naively dubbed the “Arab Spring.” On 16 December, 2010, Mohamed Bouazizi, a street vendor in Tunisia was selling produce when Ms. Faida Hamdi, a city official, came along with her entourage looking for a bribe. He had not earned enough to repay the $200 that he had borrowed to buy his goods, but she (reportedly) slapped him in the face, spat at him, confiscated his electronic weighing scales, and tossed aside his produce cart. Bouazizi went to the governor’s office to complain. When the governor refused to see him, Bouazizi set himself aflame. In short order, his self-immolation initiated the deadly demonstrations and riots throughout Tunisia and ultimately forced Zine El Abidine Ben Ali to relinquish the presidency on 14 January, 2011. He had misruled his nation for twenty-three years. The firestorm spread to Egypt, forcing Hosni Mubarak to quit after 30 years of oppressive rule. Despots in Libya, Bahrain, Yemen, and Syria, however, relied on the Islamic tradition of the rule-by-the-sword to fight back the wild fires of freedom. They exposed the naivety of the Liberal expectation that Twitter can triumph over tanks. (See FPress xxx) The protests deposed two despots, but weeding is not gardening. Bouazizi had burned himself protesting against a civilization that denies human dignity and ridicules the idea of servant-leadership. Guns and germs did not produce these noble ideas of human rights and leadership. They came from the cross of the Lord Jesus Christ. Renaissance writers Salutati, Lorenzo Valla and Pico Della Mirandella were the first to understand that Christ’s incarnation implied man’s uniqur dignity. If God had incarnated as a human being, then that proved that man was different from the other animals. He possessed a unique value and dignity that had to be respected by the state. Later reformers grasped that if if the Deity sacrificed himself on the cross to save sinful humanity, then leadership had to mean servant-hood. The Messiashship of Jesus made it obvious that the human rulers needed to be shepherds, not wolves that oppress God’s own children. Islam abhors even the idea of Incarnation and the possibility that a prophet would die on a cross. Secular intellectuals ridicule these very historical/theological truths that produced the kind of civilization that Muslim nations are now seeking. If Facebook, Twitter, and YouTube are to liberate Muslim nations from traditional tyranny, then they will have to be used to challenge not just despots but the very worldview that has dehumanized and oppressed Muslims. Western Autumn It was Blackberry, Twitter and Facebook that brought out Social Media rioters, costing British economy around $400 million. Under British law, the taxpayers will have to pay the actual insurance cost for the buildings and looted goods. These looters weren’t interested in the bookshops that made Britain great. Nor were they starving, looking for groceries or medicine. The gangs were looking for electronic gadgets, trendy clothing, and designer shoes. The London riots began because Metropolitan police branch responsible for gun crimes within the black community, shot dead 29-year old Mark Duggan. The police had been investigating him for a while and believed he was planning to take revenge on those who had stabbed to death his best friend, 23-year-old rapper, Kelvin Easton. His killers had used a broken champagne bottle to stab him at the Boheme nightclub in Mile End, East London. The police say that Mark and Kevin were linked to the Star Gang, a part of London’s blooming gang culture that has little respect for the traditional British values of lawful work and family life. The police claim that they shot Mark in self-defence. He may have been a victim of an officer’s mistake who thought that he needed to fire before Mark fired at him. But, it is important to ask ourselves – are Mark Duggan and the rioters victims of poverty or of a postmodern secular culture that has killed the soul of a once great civilization? Mark was an internet-savvy young man who used Facebook under his alias Starrish Mark. His home page had pictures of him
